Women and Family Honour

Two stories have erupted in the Indian media over the last month, both to do with young people, love and parental opposition. The first ended in tragedy, with investigation stil continuing into whether Rizwanur Rahman was murdered by his wife’s father (or arranged to have been murdered). Shocking ofcourse was the fact that the West Bengal police actively colluded in trying to separate the couple, on the grounds that they came from very different backgrounds. The second case, has a happier outcome, atleast till now – with Telegu film megastar Chiranjeevi’s daughter Sreeja leaving home to marry her boyfriend. Scary though, that she felt she had to seek police protection against her family, as she feared that they would meet the same end as Rizwanur-Priyanka.

Technically, Indian law is very clear on this – the legal marriageable age for women is 18 and 21 for men, and absolutely no statute exists that forbids people above this age to marry each other. (Well, atleast if one is male and the other is female, since Indian laws are still Victorian when it comes to homosexuality.) In practice though, as both these cases show, there is a wide gulf between law and public mentality.

Many people still view children as “property” or as some sort of owned goods who must repay parents for their good upbringing. Further instead of looking at people as individuals, there is a tendency to look at them as representatives of their families and families honour. Especially when it comes to women, their behaviour is seen as reflecting on the family’s honour. Hence, the number of insane websites where once can see Chiranjeevi fans berating Sreeja for “bringing down” Chiranjeevi’s name. (No, I am not linking to that rubbish!) Its not that sons are absolved of such expectations. Except that traditionally, society allows men a lot more leeway by giving them employment opportunities and chances to physically escape from the family network. For women, until very recently, such escape wasn’t possible, and even now, for many, it isn’t. The standards of behaviour for women are also so much higher that its easier to find fault. Things which are excusable in a son, for instance, are often not in a daughter. One hears of many families who are fine or atleast ok with sons drinking, but would be scandalised if a daughter did.

These things are slowly changing, and the tremendous public support for Rizwanur’s family and his case, is heartening. But sometimes, the change of pace is just so dishearteningly slow and the consequences so terrible.



  1. Thanks for the link. I have also written a bit about these issues here: What Rizwanur’s death means to me.
    A request; my month long persistent protest regarding Rizwanur’s death (and changing my rather poetic/literary blog) has invited attacks from all sources imaginable. Its tiring. But may I request you to comment on certain issues? Would you mind following the comments in this rather innocuous post: You’re Beautiful!?
    Thanks again!

  2. Apu, I agree with the point about parents tending to look t their children as property and this whole nonsense about family honor… but in case of Chiranjeevi’s daughter, she is just 19 – and she has been seeing this boy for the last 4 years – since she was 15! I know at 15, I thought I knew everything – now I know better 🙂 I think a lot of the parental angst may have arisen from that – and I respect it – what we see is only the “family honor” angle – and that too, as portrayed by the girl herself…

  3. LE – yes, your blog coverage is really detailed…will have a look at the post you mentioned.

    Charu – point taken. Its quite possible that even a 19 year old is still immature, and parents may feel upset because of that…but in a situation where a child feels his or her wishes will be respected, perhaps they may be prepared to wait it out for a few more years? As opposed to a situation where you fear for your life and run…Considering how close knit most Indian families are, I don’t think we will go to a situation where we expect parents to be completely uninvolved in the choices their children make, but yes, there has to be a balance no?

  4. Life has a lot to offer as we move on. Chiranjeevi’s daughter is young, “time” is going to be the biggest factor in deciding whether she’s made the right decision or done something in a haste.

    Btw excellent expression keep it up !

Comments RSS TrackBack Identifier URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s